Survey Paints Mixed View of New Yorkers’ Health
New Yorkers are getting heavier. And, like people across the country, many have difficulty sleeping and are suffering from depression. Diabetes rates in New York City remain high and racial and ethnic disparities persist. Blood levels of lead and mercury have also dropped with increased awareness and less environmental exposure.
These mixed trends were revealed in a series of studies published online July 10 in the Journal of Urban Health. Led by NYU School of Medicine and New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene researchers, the new analyses are based on physical examinations, laboratory testing, and interviews with more than 1,500 residents—a sample population picked to represent every adult, gender, and race in the city’s 5 boroughs.
The data for the new analyses were collected through the New York City Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, or NYC HANES. The special municipal survey was conducted first in 2004 and then again between 2013 and 2014 to match a similarly named federal health investigation carried out annually nationwide.
“For the first time, we are getting a long-term look at New Yorkers’ physical health using objective measures, such as blood cholesterol and sugar levels, diet, and weight, as well as mental health and chronic diseases,” says epidemiologist Lorna E. Thorpe, PhD, MPH, one of the NYC HANES study principal investigators. Dr. Thorpe helped to launch the 2004 survey while working for the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.
“This information is critical for physicians and policymakers to identify and address troubling trends, such as increasingly sedentary lifestyles, increases in screen time, more restaurant meals, and consumption of fewer fruits and vegetables,” says Dr. Thorpe, also vice chair of the Department of Population Health at NYU Langone Health. “Our study shows where we need to focus our resources to prevent and treat ill health.”
NYC HANES key findings from 2004 and 2014:
- The number of New Yorkers who were obese (having a body mass index greater than 30) increased from 27 percent to 32 percent and were mostly men. Blacks had the highest rate of obesity (37 percent), and Asians experienced the largest increase in obesity (from 20 percent to 29 percent).
- While the rise in obesity levels in New York City was less severe than observed in national trends, there were some groups who had greater increases than others, including those who had no more than a high-school education, lacked health insurance, or were immigrants.
- According to one of the studies’ authors, Pasquale Rummo, PhD, the local weight gain coincided with an average city-wide increase in ordering takeout or eating out instead of cooking at home, which rose from 2.7 meals per week to 3.8 meals per week.
- Overall, women had lower rates of risk factors for heart disease than men, with lower rates of hypertension (at 35 percent and 41 percent), fewer smoking (at 16 percent and 20 percent), and more women are eating healthy amounts of fruits and vegetables (at 6 percent) than men (at 3 percent), as recommended in national guidelines. Men, however, were more physically active than women (at 35 percent and 25 percent).
- White women have better heart health than other women and men of all races. Black women, however, fared the worst among all adults, having a 20 percent greater likelihood than white men of being overweight or obese.
- New Yorkers’ amount of physical exercise has not changed in the past decade, but those who report spending more than 3 hours per day watching television or videos online rose by 32 percent.
- Forty-one percent of New Yorkers report problems with sleep, for which deficits have been closely tied to higher risks of infection and higher rates of disease. Bisexual New Yorkers were 40 percent more likely to report greater difficulty sleeping than their straight counterparts. Researchers say the disparity may be linked to social stigma, prejudice, and stress related to minority group status.
- More than one-half million New Yorkers (8.3 percent) have symptoms of depression, with the highest rates of depression among women and Latinos. Depression is closely tied to substance use and risk behaviors for disease, such as physical inactivity and an unhealthy diet. Most people who experience depression are not receiving mental health counseling or taking medications to treat their depression. “These findings underscore the need for expanded screening and accessible mental health treatment in the city,” says Christina Norman, PhD, director of research and evaluation in the New York City Health Department’s Bureau of Mental Health and one of the studies’ authors. “Primary care physicians can play a role in identifying depression in their patients by using widely available mental health screening tools, providing treatment when needed, and referring individuals to mental health clinics when indicated.” Dr. Norman points out that in November 2015, the city launched ThriveNYC, a set of 54 initiatives to change the conversation and remove stigma surrounding mental illness and provide greater access to mental healthcare.
- Diabetes rates in New York City also remain high, with 2013 and 2014 data demonstrating a twofold disparity between whites and other groups. Diabetes rates in the city have increased moderately from 13 percent to 16 percent, with the highest proportion among Asians (24 percent) and the lowest among whites (7 percent).
NYC HANES was made possible by a mix of private and city funds. Study sponsors in 2013 and 2014 included the de Beaumont Foundation, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the Robin Hood Foundation, the New York State Health Foundation, Quest Diagnostics, the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation, and the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.
In addition to Drs. Thorpe and Rummo, other NYU Langone researchers involved in these studies are Rania Kanchi, MPH; Dustin T. Duncan, ScD; Amy Freeman, PhD; Brian D. Elbel, PhD; and Chau Trinh-Shevrin, DrPH. From the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, researchers are co-principal investigator Sharon Perlman, MPH; and co-authors Claudia Chernov, MPH; Kelsey Kepler, MPH; Christine Norman, PhD; Jennifer Hoenig, PhD; Shadi Chamany, MD, MPH; Wendy McKelvey, PhD; Paromita Hore, PhD; Winfred Wu, MD; Bahman Tabaei, MPH; Lawrence Tantay, MA; Marta Hernandez, DrPH; Carl Letamendi, PhD; and Charon Gwynn, PhD. Another researcher involved is Jesica Rodriguez-Lopez, PhD, at the Universidad De La Salle, in Bogota, Colombia.